Category Archives: Reasoning

Keikakudoori vs. John Dickson Carr : “The Three Coffins / The Hollow Man”

Solving impossible crimes one step a time. Continue reading

Posted in Mystery Genre, Reasoning | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Beatrice / Yasu : Why the Tragedy Occurs

According to EP7 Yasu has an already determined plan because of an already determined fate. The tragedy is attributed to Battler.. Battler not going away but rather to Battler coming back to the Rokkenjima – reason why the tragedy occurs. They mention the way I understood it IIRC that that the tragedy only happened because Battler came back… Continue reading

Posted in Reasoning | Tagged , , , , | 15 Comments

How Dunnit: The Bomb in all Episodes

The bomb existence is key because it is the final outcome that always happen in all games. What happens when we take out Yasu from the picture? Why does it always happen? By working under the premises of multiple scenarios I explain what happens in each case and why the result is always the same. Continue reading

Posted in Reasoning | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 8 Comments

Keikakudoori vs Ellery Queen’s The Roman Hat Mystery

When I read mystery books I don’t simply read them I try to solve them the moment I pick them up. That’s the way I find them interesting, exploring the game of: who did it, why did the culprit it, and how the did culprit it. I find those types of things most interesting when reading them […] Continue reading

Posted in Mystery Genre, Reasoning | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

EP 6 Game Results – Kanon Dead or Alive?

Before anything, I don’t completely trust the game results as I don’t completely trust the Tips/character information. However in most cases when they’re backed up by the red truths we can assume that said characters are usually dead. More to the point it tells us what characters are still alive… Continue reading

Posted in Metaphoric, Reasoning | Tagged , , , , , , , | 24 Comments

Closed Circles & Additonal corpses trick

There are things I tend I assume and others I don’t belief. I consider them as possibilities before discarding them. Additional corpses isn’t something I’ve actually believed to exist in Umineko for example. Continue reading

Posted in General overview, Reasoning | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments

Umineko and Split Personalities

EP7 really likes to push the supernatural factor but I won’t get into that until I finish completely reading the EP. As possession goes I don’t know how valid it could be but interpreting as a hint for multiple personalities […] Continue reading

Posted in Reasoning | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments